[CRISP-TEAM] Potential Questions/Comments

Izumi Okutani izumi at nic.ad.jp
Wed Jan 28 13:00:23 CET 2015


I would like to start simulation of possible questions/comments for the
Singapore meeting.

We have generally agreed on our position of each elements of the
proposal and I believe we are generally welll covered on that.

OTOH, there could be some additional questions especially related to our
process, and not necessarily the contents.

I'm intentially trying to list possible questions, even though I may not
personally agree with the assumptions behind the questions I have listed.

What I identified so far are as below -

Please feel to any other possible questions you can think of.
I hope is to consider our positions on these questions next week before

## From comments to icg-forum ##

CRISP - Process Concerns: 4 concerns listed.

We may have similar questions at ICANN52/requested to make
clarifications related to this comment.

We have briefly discussed in "More comments on the ICG-list" thread but
worth reviewing if this is sufficient.

## Other possible questions ##

a. It is not sufficient to consult RIR communities about SLA or review
   committee to be "multistakeholder".

b. RIRs/the CRISP Team didn't engage the community sufficiently in
   discussions of the proposal.

c. The CRISP team should engage the community to ensure community
   feedback will be adequately reflected in implementation.


More information about the CRISP mailing list