[CRISP-TEAM] Future steps and communicating with RIRs

[Izumi Okutani]

Thanks for trying to clarify the expected steps Mwendwa.

On 2015/01/23 16:47, Mwendwa Kivuva wrote:
> On 23 January 2015 at 04:50, Izumi Okutani <izumi at nic.ad.jp> wrote:
> 
>>   - We communicate with RIR *after* the ICG formally accepts the proposal
>>   - Clarify that this is intended for communication as reference to the RIRs
>>   - The CRISP Team would like to hear acknowlegement from RIRs about
>>     this proposal and that there are actions expected on their part, for
>>     clarity and visibility to the community that RIRs formally
>>     acknowledge this
>>
> 
> I want to understand it clearly,
> 1. ICG acknowledges receipt of CRISP proposal

2. CRISP Team formally informs the executives of the RIRs about the
proposal.

> 2. RIRs acknowledge acceptance of the proposal (I have seen great
> unofficial support from Adiel, Paul Wilson, and John Curran on our proposal)

Indeed. and as step three, we expect formal acknowledgement from RIRs
about the proposal and they will procees with actions expected from them.

> 3. ICG accepts our proposal and gives RIRs go ahead to draft contract/SLA
> and form Review Team

I'm not sure if the ICG is in the position to give it a go.
My assumption was that the RIR will start preparation without waiting
for intruction from anyone.

> 4. RIRs form Review Team and draft contract.

and consult the community where needed.

> 5. Contract is sent to ICG

In my view, it is not necessary to send the contract to the ICG.

> Are the next steps anything similar to that?


So steps in my understanding is:

1. ICG acknowledges receipt of CRISP proposal

 # It seems the timeline has changed since December so I'm not sure if
   the ICG will have a seperate phased of expressing acceptance, before
   sharing the compiled proposal in March.
   Would someone be able to confirm?

2. CRISP Team formally informs the executives of the RIRs about the
proposal.

3. RIRs formally acknowledge the proposal which require actions by the RIRs

4. RIRs prepare for implementation (form Review Committee and draft SLA)
and consult the community where needed.

5. Preparations for implementation completed before the transtion from
the NTIA (form Review Committee and SLA text ready for signing).


I welcome feedback on any point which is different from others in the
CRISP Team.

As mentioned in my earlier post, I'll also share a draft response to the
IANAXFER list several hours later.


Izumi