[CRISP-TEAM] Draft Notes CRISP 11th Teleconference (Jan 12)

Izumi Okutani izumi at nic.ad.jp
Mon Jan 19 07:58:04 CET 2015

Dear Lauraeana,

Thank you very much for your notes as always.

I just have three requests for changes, for clarity on conclusiona and
who does what.

I think you had already waited long enough, so if no other comments in
the coming 6 hours, please post this on the NRO CRISP Team website.

> 5. CRISP Team positions per issue
> a. Dispute Resolution
> IO: I sent my summary to the CRISP Team mailing list on what the issues raised and the CRISP Team’s position are. 
> IO proceeded to review the points included in her email (subject: CRISP Team position per issues discussed at the 11th call Re: Summary of Discussions point for each issue; date: January 12, 2015), quoted below.
> a. Dispute Resolution
> (Richard Hill)
> Additional description about dispute resolution: arbitration scheme.
> Either:
> - specify the same arbitration clause that is in the present MoU, namely "ICC arbitration in Bermuda" OR
> - Alternatively, "ICC arbitration in a neutral venue"
> (CRISP Team ML)
> No agreement on the suggested alternatives.
> May be OK to simply state "arbitration in a neutral venue" without specifying a scheme.”


CN Neutral is difficult to define when it comes to drafting the
contract. Arbitration in an agreed venue by all parties would work but
including the word "neutral" makes it difficult to accomodate.

> PR (via chat): Neutral is so subjective.
> AB (via chat): "Arbitration in an agreed venue" is OK for me.
> NN (via chat): +1 to Craig.
> MA (via chat): I was thinking the same thing about "neutral" because depending on definition of that word, could be difficult at a later time.
> Conclusion: CN to draft the language.

Conclusion:CN to draft the language.
> AR (via chat): Yes, agree.
> JS (via chat): Agree.
> Current position: To go ahead with the text included currently on the proposal and leave the details to the RIR legal teams.

> e. Budeget Review
> Action: NN to draft something to start a discussion on this issue on the mailing list.

Action: IO to draft something to start a discussion on this issue on the
mailing list.


On 2015/01/15 6:11, Laureana Pavon wrote:
> Dear CRISP Team,
> I'm attaching the draft notes of the 11th CRISP teleconference held last 
> Monday 12th January for your perusal.
> As always, please let me know if you have any comments or suggestions.
> Laureana Pavon
> (on behalf of the NRO Secretariat)
> _______________________________________________
> CRISP mailing list
> CRISP at nro.net
> https://www.nro.net/mailman/listinfo/crisp

More information about the CRISP mailing list