[CRISP-TEAM] Possible inconsinstency pointed out on IRP for Section III A2 and IIIA3

[Alan Barrett]

On Thu, 15 Jan 2015, Andrei Robachevsky wrote:
> I like the suggestion, but feel we lost one important point - 
> that all rights on non public information related to the IANA 
> number resource registries and corresponding services must be 
> transferred to the RIRs.  Without that it will be difficult to 
> request and accomplish the transfer of the rights when the SLAs 
> are drafted.

We previously said that such rights should be transferred to any 
successor IANA Number Servces Operator.  That text is still in 
III.A.2.  Your suggested text (quoted below) would contradict 
that.

>So I suggest an amendment:
>
>NEW:
>
>IANA Service Level Agreement Principles
>[...]
>9.	Intellectual Property Rights and Rights Over Data
>
>The RIR community must have free unlimited access to all intellectual
>property rights which are necessary for, or which relate to, the
>continuing provision of the IANA services. Such rights must also be
>available freely, without restriction, to any successor operator of the
>IANA services. All rights on non public information related to the IANA
>number resource registries and corresponding services must be
>transferred to the RIRs.
>
>The details and expectations of the RIR community on this issue are set
>out in III.A.2.

--apb (Alan Barrett)