[CRISP-TEAM] V. NTIA Requirements

[Izumi Okutani]

CRISP Team,


This is re-stating of what I think we should note about this section.
(same as my e-mail titled "Checking points before initial draft publish")

It's important to clearly show we are meeting NTIA's requirements, so
it may be worth considering putting answers according to the order
described in the ICG template.
(May not be immediately obvious, which of the answers listed as 1.-6.
 in the draft answers each questions put by ICG template below)

  - Suggestion: list answers according to order below
                (i.e, follow the same order as ICG template).

1. Support and enhance the multistakeholder model;
2. Maintain the security, stability, and resiliency of the Internet DNS;
3. Meet the needs and expectation of the global customers and partners
of the IANA services;
4. Maintain the openness of the Internet.
5. The proposal must not replace the NTIA role with a government-led or
an inter-governmental organization solution.



Izumi

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
[Current]
The proposal for the IANA stewardship transition for the Internet number
registries builds upon the existing, successful framework used by the
Internet number community today. The major characteristics of this
approach include:

1.   Global number policy development which is open and transparent to
any and all participants
2.   Continuance of existing IANA service levels, escalation processes,
and reporting mechanisms
3.   Maintenance of independent review and ratification for developed
global Internet number
resource policy
4.   Continued use of periodic third-party independent reviews of
accountability and transparency
of processes
5.   No change of the existing IANA operator for maximum stability and
security of operational
processes and systems
6.    Accountable, member-based, globally-distributed Regional Internet
Registry organizations providing routine IANA operational oversight for
the Internet number registries

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
[Suggested Change]
Changes:
- I simply put the current contents based on the order above (according
  to RFP), without changing contents/wording of the current version.
- The only thing I added is on "5. The proposal must not replace the
  NTIA role with a government-led or an inter-governmental
  organization  solution."

-------------
The proposal for the IANA stewardship transition for the Internet number
registries builds upon the existing, successful framework used by the
Internet number community today. The major characteristics of this
approach include:

1. Support and enhance the multistakeholder model;
Accountable, member-based, globally-distributed Regional Internet
Registry organizations providing routine IANA operational oversight for
the Internet number registries.

2. Maintain the security, stability, and resiliency of the Internet DNS;
No change of the existing IANA operator for maximum stability and
security of operational processes and systems.

3. Meet the needs and expectation of the global customers and partners
of the IANA services;
Continuance of existing IANA service levels, escalation processes, and
reporting mechanisms.
Maintenance of independent review and ratification for developed global
Internet number resource policy.
Continued use of periodic third-party independent reviews of
accountability and transparency of processes.

4. Maintain the openness of the Internet.
Global number policy development which is open and transparent to any
and all participants.

5. The proposal must not replace the NTIA role with a government-led or
an inter-governmental organization solution.

To adress the removal of a significant element of oversight from the
current system, our proposal is based on that a new contract be
established between the IANA functions operator and the five Regional
Internet Registries (RIRs).

This does not involve a government-led or an inter-governmental
organization.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------