[CRISP-TEAM] draft proposal: overlaps

[Alan Barrett]

On Fri, 12 Dec 2014, Andrei Robachevsky wrote:
> The amendment I am proposing has two objectives:
>
> - Align the text with the description 
> of the "overlaps" in the IETF response 
> (https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-ianaplan-icg-response), 
> and
> - Emphasize that the overlaps is a matter between the RIRs and 
> the IETF, without any need for a third party (IANA operator will 
> just implement whatever decided), rather than a "star" 
> relationship RIRs-IANA, IETF-IANA.
>
> Please let me know what you think

I agree with your "NEW" text (quoted below), but I'd suggest adding
something like your above sentence about "The IANA operator should
implement whatever is decided".

--apb (Alan Barrett)

> OLD:
>
> The specific registries that are administered by the IANA per 
> the authority delegated to the Internet Number Registry System 
> are "Autonomous System (AS) Numbers", "IANA IPv4 Address Space 
> Registry", and "IPv6 Global Unicast Address Assignments". Note 
> that within each IANA registry, there are also special-purpose 
> values, and those special-purpose values are outside the 
> Internet Numbers Registry System and instead administered under 
> the direction of the IETF. The delineation of the specific 
> ranges delegated to the Internet Number Registry system is 
> provided in RFC 7249.
>
>
> NEW:
>
> The IETF is responsible for policy relating to the entire IP 
> address space and AS number space.  Through the IANA protocol 
> parameters registries, the IETF delegates unicast IP address 
> ("IANA IPv4 Address Space Registry" and "IPv6 Global Unicast 
> Allocations Registry") and AS number space ("Autonomous System 
> (AS) Numbers Registry”) to the RIR system [RFC7020]. Note 
> that within each IANA registry, there are also special-purpose 
> registries, which are outside the Internet Numbers Registry 
> System and instead administered under the direction of the 
> IETF. The delineation of the specific ranges delegated to the 
> Internet Number Registry system is provided in RFC 7249.