[CRISP-TEAM] draft proposal: overlaps

[Andrei Robachevsky]

Dear colleagues,

As we discussed before we need to bring substantive issues for the
discussion in this team. The matter I am bringing up below is relatively
minor, but still it is important that it doesn't sneak in the document
as part of editorial changes, but gets proper review. I suggest we open
a separate mail thread for each substantive issue.

The amendment I am proposing has two objectives:

- Align the text with the description of the "overlaps" in the IETF
response (https://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-ietf-ianaplan-icg-response), and
- Emphasize that the overlaps is a matter between the RIRs and the IETF,
without any need for a third party (IANA operator will just implement
whatever decided), rather than a "star" relationship RIRs-IANA, IETF-IANA.

Please let me know what you think

Thanks,

Andrei



OLD:

The specific registries that are administered by the IANA per the
authority delegated to the Internet Number Registry System are
"Autonomous System (AS) Numbers", "IANA IPv4 Address Space Registry",
and "IPv6 Global Unicast Address Assignments". Note that within each
IANA registry, there are also special-purpose values, and those
special-purpose values are outside the Internet Numbers Registry System
and instead administered under the direction of the IETF. The
delineation of the specific ranges delegated to the Internet Number
Registry system is provided in RFC 7249.


NEW:

The IETF is responsible for policy relating to the entire IP address
space and AS number space.  Through the IANA protocol parameters
registries, the IETF delegates unicast IP address ("IANA IPv4 Address
Space Registry" and "IPv6 Global Unicast Allocations Registry") and AS
number space ("Autonomous System (AS) Numbers Registry”) to the RIR
system [RFC7020]. Note that within each IANA registry, there are also
special-purpose registries, which are outside the Internet Numbers
Registry System and instead administered under the direction of the
IETF. The delineation of the specific ranges delegated to the Internet
Number Registry system is provided in RFC 7249.